Butterfly Try-All Set vs Single Decks: Which Saves More?
By Marked Playing Cards for Magicians | Butterfly Playing Cards ... | Published: 2026-10-14
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Butterfly Try-All Set (3 decks, one design, three paper stocks) with buying Butterfly decks individually. See which route saves money and which helps you find your ideal stock.
Quick answer
If your goal is to find your favorite paper stock, the Butterfly Try-All Set (3 Decks) is the more efficient choice: three identical designs on three different stocks in one limited set. If you already know which stock and edition you prefer, buying single decks or a themed multipack usually gives you more of exactly what you want. The Try-All Set is about discovery; singles and multipacks are about stocking up.
What the Try-All Set actually gives you
The Try-All Set is built around one question: do you like your cards thin or thick, soft or springy? It contains three decks with identical design but three different paper stocks, so the only variable you feel is the stock itself. It is a limited edition of 500 sets, produced with Room One for ACC 2025. That makes it a testing tool first and a performance deck second.
When buying single decks makes more sense
Single decks let you choose a specific edition and quantity. For example, the Butterfly Workers Edition Silver is a single limited deck with a silver-foiled back, court cards, Ace of Spades, and one Joker, printed by Cartamundi on Slimline stock with True Linen B9 Finish using cold foil technology. It also includes a double backer and a blank face card. If you already know you want that specific finish and those gaffs, buying it directly is more practical than paying for a stock test you do not need.
Multipacks: the middle path
If you have already found your preferred Butterfly deck, a multipack lowers your cost per deck. The Butterfly Workers Edition V2 (12 Blue Decks) is a 20% saving on twelve blue decks, and it uses the standard white-bordered back design that many magicians prefer. The Futterfly Playing Cards (6 Decks) is a 15% saving on six decks, and it is the deck with the black border used in a Penn & Teller: Fool Us performance. These bundles do not help you compare stocks, but they do reduce the price of decks you already trust.
How to decide without wasting money
Start with your actual goal. If you cannot yet describe the stock you like in terms of thickness or spring, the Try-All Set is the only option here that answers that question directly. If you can already name the edition and finish you want, skip the test set and put the money toward a multipack or a specific single deck. There is no rule that you must own every stock before you perform.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Try-All Set: discovery vs. quantity: You get three decks to compare stocks, but only three decks total, and they share one design. You are paying for the comparison, not for volume. Choose this if finding your stock matters more than having spare decks.
- Single decks: precision vs. per-deck price: Buying one Workers Edition Silver gives you a specific limited deck with cold foil, a double backer, and a blank face. You pay full single-deck price and get no stock comparison. Choose this if you already know the exact edition and finish you want.
- Multipacks: savings vs. commitment: The 12-deck Workers Edition V2 saves 20% and the 6-deck Futterfly bundle saves 15%, but both lock you into one design and one stock. Choose these only after you have already settled on the deck you like.
Product facts that affect the decision
- Butterfly Playing Cards Try-All Set (3 Decks): Butterfly Playing Cards Try-All Set (3 Decks): identical design on 3 different paper stocks, limited edition of 500 sets, produced with Room One for ACC 2025. It is the only option here that isolates paper stock as the variable, so it is the fastest way to learn your preference.
- Futterfly Playing Cards (6 Decks): Futterfly Playing Cards (6 Decks): a discounted bundle of six decks, saving 15%, and the black-bordered deck used in a Penn & Teller: Fool Us performance. If you already like the Futterfly design, this bundle lowers your cost per deck compared with buying six singles.
- Butterfly Playing Cards Workers Edition V2 (12 Blue Decks): Butterfly Playing Cards Workers Edition V2 (12 Blue Decks): save 20% on twelve blue decks, with the standard white-bordered back design preferred by many magicians. This is the strongest per-deck saving in the catalog, but it only makes sense if you already know you want this edition and color.
- Butterfly Playing Cards Workers Edition Silver: Butterfly Playing Cards Workers Edition Silver: silver-foiled back design, court cards, Ace of Spades, and one Joker; printed by Cartamundi on Slimline stock with True Linen B9 Finish using cold foil technology; includes a double backer and a blank face card; limited edition of 500 decks. A single deck with specific finish and gaff cards is better bought directly when you already know that is what you want, rather than as part of a stock test.
Which option fits you?
Best for
- Magicians who want to compare paper stocks before committing to a favorite
- Buyers who value a limited-edition set produced with Room One for ACC 2025
- Anyone who cannot yet describe whether they prefer thin or thick, soft or springy cards
Not for
- Magicians who already know their preferred Butterfly edition and stock
- Buyers who need a large number of identical decks for practice or resale
- Anyone specifically wanting the silver-foiled Workers Edition Silver or the black-bordered Futterfly design
