Tips for Breaking in Stiff New Decks: Soften Your Butterfly Cards
By Butterfly Playing Cards | Published: 2026-08-23
Category: Tips & Care
New playing cards often feel stiff and hard to handle. Learn practical tips to break in your Butterfly deck for smoother shuffles, fans, and flourishes.
There’s nothing quite like the feel of a fresh deck of playing cards. The crisp snap, the smooth finish, and the perfect edges—it’s a card enthusiast’s dream. But for many, that new deck stiffness can be a hurdle, especially if you’re used to a broken-in deck that fans effortlessly and springs with ease. If you’ve just unboxed a new Butterfly deck and it feels a bit too rigid, don’t worry—you’re not alone.
In this guide, we’ll explore why new decks are stiff, how to break them in properly, and share practical tips to soften your cards without damaging them. Whether you’re a cardist, magician, or casual player, these techniques will help you get the most out of your new Butterfly Playing Cards.
Why Are New Decks Stiff?
New playing cards are manufactured with a fresh layer of finish and are tightly compressed in the box. The cards haven’t had time to flex, and the air between them hasn’t been worked out. This is especially true for premium decks like Butterfly Playing Cards, which use high-quality card stock and a unique finish that feels great but can initially be a bit stiff.
The stiffness is also a result of the cards being perfectly flat and stacked. When you handle them, the friction between the cards is higher because they haven’t been separated and flexed yet. Over time, as you use them, the cards will naturally loosen up, but you can speed up the process with a few simple techniques.
- New cards are tightly packed and have a fresh finish that increases friction.
- The card stock is stiff to ensure durability, but it softens with use.
- Breaking in your deck helps it perform better for fans, springs, and shuffles.
The Best Ways to Break In Your New Deck
One of the simplest and most effective ways to break in a new deck is to handle it. Shuffle the cards repeatedly, do some basic cuts, and practice your favorite moves. The more you handle the deck, the faster it will loosen up. This is a natural process that works with any deck, including the Butterfly Playing Cards Workers Edition V2 (Red), which is designed for daily practice.

Another popular method is to 'riffle' the cards. Hold the deck in one hand and use your thumb to riffle through the cards from the back to the front, then repeat. This helps separate the cards and introduces air between them, reducing the stickiness and stiffness. Do this for a few minutes, and you’ll notice a significant difference in flexibility.
- Shuffle and cut the deck repeatedly to loosen the cards.
- Riffle the cards to introduce air and reduce friction.
- Practice cardistry moves like the spring and fan to flex the cards.
Using the 'Faro Shuffle' Technique
The faro shuffle is not only a beautiful move but also an excellent way to break in a new deck. By interleaving the cards perfectly, you’re forcing each card to flex and move against its neighbors, which helps to soften the deck evenly. If you’re new to the faro, start with a gentle approach and gradually increase the pressure as the deck becomes more pliable.
For a deck like the Original 3rd Edition Butterfly Playing Cards (Red), which is a favorite among cardists, practicing the faro shuffle will not only improve your skills but also help you break in the deck faster. The key is consistency—do a few faro shuffles each day, and within a week, your deck will feel much more broken in.

- Practice the faro shuffle to flex the entire deck evenly.
- Start with a gentle faro and increase pressure as the deck loosens.
- Consistent practice will yield the best results.
The 'Pressure and Flex' Method
If you want to speed up the break-in process, you can use a more direct method. Hold the deck in both hands and apply gentle pressure to the center, bending the deck slightly. Then, rotate the deck and repeat. This helps to flex the cards and loosen the fibers in the card stock. Be careful not to bend too much, as you don’t want to crease the cards.
Another technique is to place the deck under a heavy book for a few hours. This applies even pressure across the entire deck, helping to flatten and soften the cards. This is a great option if you’re not in a hurry and want to avoid any manual work. Just make sure the deck is in a card sleeve or box to protect it from dust and moisture.
- Gently bend the deck in your hands to flex the cards.
- Place the deck under a heavy book for a few hours to apply even pressure.
- Always handle your deck with clean, dry hands to avoid damage.
How Long Does It Take to Break In a Deck?
The time it takes to break in a new deck varies depending on how often you use it and the techniques you employ. For casual players, it might take a few weeks of regular use. For cardists who practice daily, you can expect a deck to feel broken in within a few days to a week.
Butterfly decks are known for their durability and long lifespan, so the break-in period is a small price to pay for a deck that will last. The Butterfly Playing Cards Black & White Unmarked is a great option if you prefer an unmarked deck that you can break in and use for any purpose. Remember, the more you handle your deck, the faster it will soften.
- Daily practice can break in a deck in under a week.
- Casual use may take a few weeks.
- Butterfly decks are durable and worth the break-in time.
Avoid These Common Mistakes
While breaking in your deck, it’s important to avoid certain mistakes that can damage your cards. One common error is over-bending the deck, which can cause permanent creases. Always apply gentle pressure and gradually increase as the deck becomes more flexible.
Another mistake is using excessive moisture or oils to soften the cards. This can ruin the finish and make the cards sticky. Stick to dry methods like shuffling, riffling, and gentle bending. If you’re looking for a deck that’s already broken in, consider the Butterfly Playing Cards Workers Edition V2 (6 Mixed Decks), which offers a variety of decks that are designed for heavy use and may come slightly more flexible.
- Avoid over-bending, which can crease the cards.
- Never use water or oil to soften cards—it damages the finish.
- Store your deck in a cool, dry place to maintain its condition.
Final Thoughts on Breaking In Your Butterfly Deck
Breaking in a new deck is a rite of passage for any card enthusiast. It’s a process that connects you with your cards and prepares them for the magic and cardistry to come. By following the tips in this guide, you’ll have your Butterfly deck feeling smooth and flexible in no time.
Remember, patience is key. Don’t rush the process, and enjoy the journey of getting to know your new deck. Whether you’re using the Original 3rd Edition Butterfly Playing Cards (Blue) or any other Butterfly deck, the break-in period is an investment in performance.
With these tips, you’ll be able to break in your stiff new deck quickly and safely. Remember to handle your cards regularly, use gentle pressure, and avoid moisture. For a deck that’s already known for its smooth handling, consider the Original 3rd Edition Butterfly Playing Cards (Red) – it’s a favorite among cardists and will reward you with excellent performance once broken in. Happy shuffling!



